X was actually smiling for the first time in quite a while. Y was pounding on a set of bongos and singing her head off, oblivious to everything but the tune of the day. As the last line died out and the final finger roll crept ever so slowly and softly to a close Y leaped up, flipped backwards and landed in an impressive split. “Thank you, thank you very much,” said Y in her best Elvis voice, “God Bless and goodnight everyone.”
“That was the best set we’ve done in a long time, Y.” laughed X, clapping. “We need to get that one pressed somehow.”
“No!”
“Are you kidding, it was great! What’s your problem? All you have to do is get those lyrics down on paper and we’ll take it into the studio.”
“I don’t write lyrics anymore, you know that. Can’t do it.” said Y sadly.
“Can’t, or won’t? Looks like won’t from over here,” responded X with a look of confusion. “What’s your hang up with writing the lyrics down?”
Y suddenly looked exhausted. She picked up a kazoo and played a string of notes on it. “How do you feel about that melody line?” she asked X.
“It’s ok, a little scratchy on the kazoo, try the piano and I’ll let you know.”
Y walked over to the piano and picked out the same tune with one finger. “Now?”
“Yeah, I like it, crisp, clean, makes me think of being a kid again,” said X.
“Exactly, most people have pretty good memories of this tune,” said Y. “Maybe even 98 out of 100 would smile when they heard it. Now how about if I add this?” She added full chords to the melody line. It sounded hearty and warm in the night.
“Even better, what are you getting at? I don’t get it, everybody knows that tune. Are you saying a few hate it so we shouldn’t play it?”
“No, not really. It’s just music. Anybody that hates it just won’t listen to it or think about it at all. But what if I add this..”
She played the tune again and sang, “Bah, bah, black sheep, have you any wool?” Y took her hands off the keys and looked searchingly at X.
“I still like it, makes me remember the cubby I had in kindergarten and the smell of paste for some odd reason.”
“Exactly so,” said Y. “But remember the 2 people that didn’t like the music in the first place? What if now one of them decides that the way to make the annoying music stop is to start telling people that the song is unfair to sheep? Says it celebrates the fact that humans have learned to indenture the poor sheep and exploit them for their wool? What if the other one decides that the song is a thinly veiled racial slur? What if they take to the streets and protest the song? Somehow, someday, the song will disappear. People who enjoyed the song to begin with will just stop singing it because those negative connotations are hard to shake once they start up.”
“You’re kidding me, that would never happen,” said X. “People just aren’t that extreme.”
“Yeah X, they are. There will always be someone who will claim that the lyrics mean something sinister, no matter what the writer really meant. Mostly people who don’t like music to begin with and just see protesting lyrics as a way to draw attention to themselves. That’s why I don’t write down the lyrics anymore. If I don’t write them down they can’t be twisted like that.” Y was more serious than X had ever seen her. She played the opening notes of the song again. Her fingers passed over the keys slowly , with a hint of despair. This time X picked up her trumpet and joined in. “I’ll miss you,” whispered the horn to the piano.
_________________